Ok, so, i have to do something for my physics class involving disproving the physics of something that happens in a movie. At a conference held at the jet propulsion laboratory in california, nasa experts have voted 2012 the most scientifically flawed and absurd science fiction film ever made. The truth is the complete opposite, the psychic by forcing the client to. Sep 19, 2012 2012 2009 in 2012, massive earthquakes, volcanic eruptions and tsunamis plague the earth. I have come up with several ideas to make this work, including scenes from. One of the behindthescene things for up is the realistic simulation of many aspect of the movie. The fiction world has long been full of cool science and technology that eventually sneaks its way into real life. The physics of 2012 30 march 07 update 102010 aside from the mechanism described in this article, i believe that earth passing through, or being irradiated by, a dense cloud of etheric energy would also explain the phenomena allegedly associated with the 2012 dimensional shift idea. Published on jun 4, 2012 this is a little project i did for my ap physics class where i explain a few examples in popular movies of absolute ignorance of real physics. The bad thing about this film is that it could make some people. Ordinary and not so ordinary people strive to survive and cope with all the big set pieces disasters that ensue. However, physics would say that frodo experiences massive blunt force trauma broken bones, internal injuries. Certainly, the screenwriters had the mayan calendar in mind.
This is a little project i did for my ap physics class where i explain a few examples in popular movies of absolute ignorance of real physics. Often outsmarted,the coyote seems to fall off a lot of cliffs. Many of the bad opinions surrounding this film seems to be viewers simply missing the point. My publicly admitted mancrush on clooney plus my notsoinner physics nerd made that scene hard to watch.
With john cusack, thandie newton, chiwetel ejiofor, amanda peet. The shifty science behind the movie 2012 softpedia news. Apr 12, 2011 a movie called the big bang will be coming out soon, and although its more of a detectiveaction movie, it seems to be somewhat set on a particle physics backdrop. With patrick labyorteaux, julie mccullough, katie wilson, nick afanasiev. As explained in the introduction for the movie, the fall is a tunnel bored through the center of the earth that connects the fictional united federation of britain and the colony, which is located in present. Physics in film a blog to accompany a course of the same. A movie called the big bang will be coming out soon, and although its more of a detectiveaction movie, it seems to be somewhat set on a particle physics backdrop. Watch the clip and describe the physics that is defied. Top 5 science done wrong moments in movies science. Michael brotherton, author and assistant professor in the department of physics and astronomy at the university of wyoming in an early shot in the movie, we see a light moving across the sky. This is a little project i did for my ap physics class where.
Incidentally, the tall evillooking russian is practically from my home town, and its interesting to see a guy i use to cross at school and the local gym show up along side. I hate bad movies regardless of whether the science is good or not. First, let me estimate the values for s 1 and s 2 from the diagram. And what would happen when the bathtub suddenly stops. In 1982 a russian physicist discovered something extraordinary was behind the strange radar anomalies he was recording.
Heres what gravity gets right and wrong about space. When frodo gets stabbed by the cave troll, frodos mithril shirt protects him from being pierced. The 5 worst natural disaster movies that have nothing to. This is what 2012 was saying, yet the megatsunamis still occured against all of the laws of physics. The movie traces the journey of two astronauts to save themselves after their shuttle gets clobbered by space debris from a destructed satellite. There is an explosion and space and you can hear it. I will just go ahead and put the height of the center of mass for the hulk while standing at 1. Over the moon in love 2020 romance hallmark movie 2020 new love hallmark movies 2020 duration. Too bad science shows backward time travel is impossibleor, if it is. What are some movie scenes with really bad physics.
Something dark, which will eventually alter the path of mankind. Much of the story for this science fiction thriller based loosely on a short story by philip k. A disaster movie from the director of independence day and also the day after tomorrow. Nasas silly scifi film list 2012 the most flawed w. The nostromo is a snarl of leaking hydraulic lines, cramped eating. And that is my poor excuse for unashamedly loving bad action films that make absolutely no scientific sense. People discover that the world is going to come to an end in 2012 when the continents will collapse and massive floods will follow. The director could just have easily had him collide with the iss or have his suit receive damage but instead chose this emotional scene where stone is panicking to help kowalski and kowalski calmly detaches himself in order to save stone. Dec 28, 2012 the most egregious science mistakes in movies this year.
Gravity is an enthralling, beautifully shot film with strong performances, especially from sandra bullock. The most egregious science mistakes in movies this year. The scientific community wants to see the world in a way thats at least marginally believable, without any huge infractions against the basic rules of physics, math, biology and chemistry. In the name of physics decency, to protect the minds of children everywhere, so that they may grow up in a world where they know the difference between speed and velocity, we have taken the responsibility to rate movies for their portrayal of excessively bad physics. Nasas silly scifi film list 2012 the most flawed w video. The ice sinks when its blown up, and even if there were pieces of metal on top of the ice, it shouldnt. Still, there are plenty of ways science advising can go wrong miscommunication, script. In the underwater scene when rex blows up the ice pack, ice appears to be denser than water in this situation. But theres only so much belief you can suspend before a movie crosses the line from fictional into ludicrous. Sep 07, 2007 hollywood physics take a look at a few of cinemas most mindboggling moments of scientific inaccuracyplus a few rare films that manage to get things mostly right september 7, 2007. Flip phones, for example, were dreamed up on star trek long before they made it. A group of graduate students in physics at the university of leicester. But coyote doesnt seem to start falling until he realizes. Dec 28, 2010 this is one of the worst bad science movie lists ive seen the criteria are far from relevant for space related movies lars says.
Theres no acting masterclass, political agenda or environmental message. The avengers movie amazing feats of physics live science. Imdb devastating earthquakes, volcanic eruptions, an ice world, and tsunamis are all crammed into 2012, one of the absolute worst natural disaster movies of all time. Oct 09, 2009 the 20 worst science and technology errors in films. This is especially true in the scenes involving those numerous balloons. Physics students rip apart the science behind the movie. This is one of the worst bad science movie lists ive seen the criteria are far from relevant for space related movies lars says. Maybe youre one of the lucky few who can move past the mistakes and still enjoy the film. The utopian layouts and handy fasterthanlight engines of most scifi spacecraft are nowhere to be found in aliens spaceship. A volcanic eruption in iceland sends a glacier towards north america, causing everything in its path to freeze.
A frustrated writer struggles to keep his family alive when a series of global catastrophes threatens to annihilate mankind. You are watching your favorite science fiction moviebut wait. What ad astra gets wrong about space travel, astronomy. I will admit that wanted definitely does test the laws of physics, it isnt actually breaking them. Much to jon stewarts chagrin and hardly contained amusement tyson has pointed out on multiple occasions that the globe shown during the opening segment of the daily show is merrily whirling in the wrong direction. This is a major reason for their list of bad science films because they do worry many people. Pixar animators are wellversed in physics, and have tried to model them according to the laws of physics. After seeing the much hyped movie 2012, which began running in theaters. But as tyson clarified in a later followup on facebook, gravity also got lots of things right. Also neglected are the laws of physics and more geological facts for the sake of a dramatic movie. Disaster movie maven roland emmerich independence day, the day after tomorrow crafts this apocalyptic scifi thriller following the prophecy stated by the ancient mayan calendar, which says that. The 20 worst science and technology errors in films telegraph. Jan 17, 2012 the utopian layouts and handy fasterthanlight engines of most scifi spacecraft are nowhere to be found in aliens spaceship. What are some good films that, at least momentarily, ignored basic laws of physics.
What ad astra gets wrong about space travel, astronomy, and. The rest of us flee to the concession stand or hit the browse button on. A family man struggles to escape the onslaught of the coming ice age. Dec 05, 2009 this is what 2012 was saying, yet the megatsunamis still occured against all of the laws of physics. Jan 07, 2011 at a conference held at the jet propulsion laboratory in california, nasa experts have voted 2012 the most scientifically flawed and absurd science fiction film ever made. Jun 03, 2012 also neglected are the laws of physics and more geological facts for the sake of a dramatic movie. Physics students rip apart the science behind the movie armageddon nick collins.
Transporter 2 a man jumps out a window about 3 stories high. The most egregious science mistakes in movies this year popular. Physics movies mainstream movies with physics in them. Review the most sciencedistorting movies of 2012 in this gallery. Michael brotherton, author and assistant professor in the department of physics and astronomy at the university of wyoming in an early shot in the movie, we see a. This is a great oldfashioned art deco movie house, and the owner truly loves movies. At the start hes flying around the space shuttle at who knows what speed in his jetpack, mouthing off about random stuff and generally. Neil degrasse tyson is arguably one of the most popular debunkers of sloppy science. The 20 worst science and technology errors in films. The ability to totally ignore physics scientific scribbles.
The general population enjoys the spectacle of actionpacked scripts. This is the oldest trick in the book, a psychic does this so they can claim that they are not fishing for information, or that the client is telling them things and so on. In this issue, argonne nuclear scientist keith bradley debunks the fusion bomb in the dark knight rises, the final installment in christopher nolans batman trilogy. The 5 worst natural disaster movies that have nothing to do. Coyotes favourite past time is to chase around the road runner. Like many people, i went to see total recall recently. Lots of things dont make sense from a physics point of view inside the matrix itself, but we can forgive. Theatricality and deception are powerful agents to the uninitiated, says the villain bane, batmans rather eloquent enemy in the dark night rises. Any movie that shows someone getting thrown backwards by a bullet hitting them is defying the law of physics which refer to the opposite and equal reaction which states that the force of a bullet flying must also be transmitted to the shooter. The set designers show an impressive eye for realism. As much as we all loved watching gravity, its important that we get you acquainted with various scientific aspects depicted in the movie and see how realistic this film really is. But ironically, banes most terrifying threata fusion reactor.
741 326 1295 1166 475 168 1012 253 1218 1220 978 1185 576 625 1245 333 639 785 993 1219 1445 392 1315 781 202 345 1069 535 699 510 623 29 786 1201 392 11 410 43 1011 595 1300